Theresa Mutual
Insurance Company

Our Philosophy

"Neighbor Helping Neighbor"

It's an idea as old as civilization itself and is the concept behind Theresa Mutual Insurance Company. We believe that the "neighbor helping neighbor" policy is what has kept the company in existence since 1879. We offer insurance coverages for farms, homes, mobile homes, rental dwellings, tenants, and small businesses. Auto insurance is also available with discount through 1st Auto & Casualty.

Our Service Area

Our friendly, knowledgeable agents understand your insurance needs and service the following Wisconsin counties: